facebookInvesting long-term with a Robo: Does it make sense to make partial withdrawals in a bull market and make lump-sum deposits when in a bear market? - Seedly

Anonymous

22 Sep 2020

Robo-Advisors

Investing long-term with a Robo: Does it make sense to make partial withdrawals in a bull market and make lump-sum deposits when in a bear market?

Or does that not make sense considering the base proportion of the ETFs held under each index and for compounding? Better to hold and deposit more in a bear market?

Thanks and excuse my beginner question.

Discussion (3)

What are your thoughts?

Learn how to style your text

Chin Guo Qiang

26 Dec 2023

Assistant Vice President, IT EUC at OCBC

For this question, it will be best to stay invested over a longer horizon (long period of time), at least for the risk mitigation part.

Investing at certain time points may lead to a case of "Buy High, Sell Low", of which the entry point for the investments can carry a premium rate, and not easy to gain more returns due to relatively higher cost points for initial entry into the market(s).

Endowus

22 Sep 2020

Hi Anon,

It is difficult to time the market. We only know when a bull run stops when it actually stops - at any point of time it is impossible for us to look ahead and be able to tell consistently where the market is moving.

The less emotionally driven way of investing is to invest consistently the full amount that you are comfortable investing in, so that you do not build up a huge pile of cash to be invested.

You can read more about it here https://sg.endow.us/3hTWOC1

Investment should be done with a long term mindset, if you were to sell and make some gains and the ...

Write your thoughts