Lim Qin Da
20 May 2020
Business Administration & Analytics at National University of Singapore
Answers from the panel!
Michele (Stashaway): Owners of Smartly decided that they were not able to be a profitable company, so they decided to liquidate the business. It was actually not linked to the market crash. If you're a monthly customer of Smartly, they would have sent out an email saying that you could move your funds to Stashaway at a discount, which is why I am aware of this because we offered this to the Smartly owners. Investors withdrew the money, some moved it to Stashaway and some received the cash. They had to liquidate their holdings and reinvest because it was too small and not feasible to create such a complex process to move their funds. However, moving assets and liquidating them actually has the same effect - if one the same day you reinvest in another platform, then nothing will happen, other than the inconvenience.
Sam (Endowus): The way that Smartly unwinds is something that the company has to consider. The way that Smartly is set up is in such a way that they had to liquidate the clients' money. They had to sell down, take that money and reinvest it. This is not optimal, especially due to the timing, it wasn't a very optimal to sell out to the market and difficult to get on to another platform due to various reasons. However, all of us here have robust systems to tackle this issue.
For more discussions on SeedlyTV S2E04, you could check out the video and Q&A here!
View 1 replies
Singapore market pie too small, too many competitors, hard to made a decent profit in the long-term. kinda like how retail banking here in singapore is mainly dominated by the 3 local banks
tbh,i believe it is in the interest of Singapore retail invesots for robo-adviors number to be at most 5. this would give sufficient consolidation of fragmented retail assets, improvement in AUM also means lower fees can be passed down to clients
24 Mar 2020
Tag Team Member at Kenichi Tag Team
Just received an email from Smartly:
Thank you for investing with Smartly. We are writing to inform ...
Read 1 other comments with a Seedly account
You will also enjoy exclusive benefits and get access to members only features.
Sign up or login with an email here
Write your thoughts