facebookRobo War Experiment July Update - Seedly

Tan Choong Hwee

Solutions Specialist at Providend

Edited 05 Aug 2021

Robo-Advisors

Robo War Experiment July Update

As a follow up on my mid year performance update (https://seedly.sg/posts/mid-year-performance-up...), here is the July update. I have made several changes to the benchmark section:

  1. Added MSCI ACWI as benchmark.
  2. Some feedback from Seedly community that my robo performance was based on SGD, but the benchmark was based on USD. So, I have taken FX rate into account for the benchmark performance.
  3. My original benchmark performance was based on a lumpsum investment in Jan. However, my robo was lumpsum in Jan, but DCA from Feb onwards. So, I have done up a simulation of benchmark performance with the same lumpsum to DCA ratio on exact same dates of investments.
  4. What I didn't cater for is the dividend returns for indices, simply because I don't have a source of total return data for all 3 indices.
  5. Another discrepancy would be indices are not tradeable. We would have to use index ETFs to simulate, and there would be additional costs involved (TER, tracking errors, brokerage fees, bid/ask spreads, etc.). Too much efforts to just getting a feel of the robo performance against benchmark indices.

The source of indices and FX rates are:

MSCI World Index - https://www.investing.com/indices/msci-world-hi...

MSCI ACWI - https://www.investing.com/indices/msci-world-st...

S&P 500 - https://www.investing.com/indices/us-spx-500-hi...

FX Rates - https://www.x-rates.com/historical/

Discussion (5)

What are your thoughts?

Learn how to style your text

I’m taking notes, thanks for sharing this.

How long do you intend to continue this experiment?

asking because since all 3 robos you are tracki...

Write your thoughts

Related Products

StashAway

StashAway

Verified Account

4.7

1293 Reviews

StashAway Simple Guaranteed 3.55% p.a. (Guaranteed rate)

Cash Management

INSTRUMENTS

None

ANNUAL MANAGEMENT FEE

None

MINIMUM INVESTMENT

3.5%

EXPECTED ANNUAL RETURN

Mobile App

PLATFORMS

Endowus

Endowus

Verified Account

4.7

656 Reviews

Syfe

Syfe

Verified Account

4.6

930 Reviews