Would it be a better choice to invest in robo advisors or ETFs? - Seedly
Seedly logo
Seedly logo
Ā 

AMA The Fifth Person

ETF

Robo-Advisors

Investments

Anonymous

Asked on 20 Feb 2019

Would it be a better choice to invest in robo advisors or ETFs?

0 comments

9 answers

Answer Now

Answers (9)

Sort By

Arpita Mukherjee
Arpita Mukherjee, Community Evangelist at Kristal.AI
Level 6. Master
Answered on 29 Oct 2019

Let's start with understanding both the concepts. Robo-advisories are platforms that help you assess your risk appetite, create your portfolio accordingly and then choose different strategies, assets and instruments that you can invest your money in. On the other hand, ETFs are instruments that you can invest in. You can go for different ETFs, and invest in them through a Robo-advisory. These are still not very different from your ordinary financial advisors as both options will still have a management fee incurred for users. The difference lies with the amount, as Robo-advisors have lower management fees. And the best part is that they give you the most unbiased advice.

I work at Kristal.AI, and my mojo is to help people make the right financial decisions. If you think I helped you, do give me "Thumbs up". If you think my response was biased let me know, I will work on it.

I hope this helps you make the right decision.

0 comments

šŸ‘ 1
Sarah Chan
Sarah Chan, Business Administration at NUS
Level 6. Master
Answered on 03 Jul 2019

Hi anon,

I've recently answered a similar question and did a thorough analysis here! Do take a look :) At the end of the day, ask yourself the usual questions before investing:

  1. What's your risk appetite?

  2. What's your starting capital? Are you alright with paying for intermediary fees?

  3. How much do you know about each type of investment?

  4. How much effort and time would you like to spend on the investment?

Ultimately, diversification is key! So you can actually invest in BOTH Robo-Advisors and ETFs at the same time :)

0 comments

šŸ‘ 1

Robo-advisor buys ETFs for you. You pay more fees to robo compared to ETFs for them to help you manage your investments. DIY ETFs on the other hand is slightly cheaper in terms of expenses and you can customize it more differently compared to robo with fixed allocations based on your risk appetite. Both are mainly for passive investors just that DIY ETFs will have to buy yourself through a broker every time you want to invest more. If you wan more flexibility in ETFs and ok with doing research yourself and buying monthly yourself through a broker, go for DIY ETFs. If you want to do a totally hands free investment and ok with paying abit more fees and abit less flexible, go for ROBO.

0 comments

šŸ‘ 1
Geraldo L.
Geraldo L.
Level 7. Grand Master
Answered on 09 Mar 2020

I prefer to go with ETFs because there's greater control over you own investments and the costs are typically lower. With that being said, it requires a lot more discipline and time to do so and it might not be suitable for everyone. If you're willing to put in the effort, DIY investing is not that difficult.

0 comments

šŸ‘ 0
Frankie Rappaport
Frankie Rappaport
Top Contributor

Top Contributor (Jul)

Level 9. God of Wisdom
Answered on 05 Mar 2020

Depends on your own effort, interest and motivation.

Dedicating a lot of reading in the beginning surely can make you an independent

self-directed investor (like I did myself). You don't need many books, websites with balanced unbiased information are important. Then you can do all with ETFs what robos could do for you only for higher costs/fees.

To be successful avoid: mutual funds, unit trusts, options, blockchain, greed ...

more on my private thinking here:

https://seedly.sg/questions/what-to-do-with-15k-invest-save

0 comments

šŸ‘ 0
MT2020
MT2020
Level 7. Grand Master
Answered on 25 Feb 2020

For robo advisor, it is totally hands free as the companies will do everything from investing to conversion of currencies for you. However, on top of the etfs fee you have to pay, there is also a robo advisor fee as well. For DIY in etfs, you can choose which etfs to invest so you can get more freedom and you do not have to pay any extra fees other then the etfs expense ratio fees.

0 comments

šŸ‘ 0
Victor Chng
Victor Chng, Co-Founder at Fifth Person Pte Ltd
Level 6. Master
Answered on 20 Feb 2019

Hi,

I think you should consider ETF over robo advisors because there are extra fee involve for robo advisors.

0 comments

šŸ‘ 0
Zann Chua
Zann Chua
Level 6. Master
Answered on 20 Feb 2019

Hello!

Both roboadvisors and ETFs are good to invest for younger investers. Roboadvisors actually invests in ETFs that are recommended for you based on your portfolio. Si I think the question would be more on whether to invest in ETFs yourself or using Roboadviosrs. If you are more of a passive investor and is comfortable with letting these roboadvisors doing your investing for you, then investing in roboadvisors would be a good choice. If you are more comfortable with actively monitoring the markets and take an active approach towards investing, then investing in ETFs yourself would be a better choice.

Hope this helps!

0 comments

šŸ‘ 0

Robo advisors can be a great solution for beginner investors, young professionals who want to put their portfolio on automation. Robo advisors are not financial planners and are generally good for basic financial assistance.

ETFs on the other hand is also good for investors. Traded like stocks, these can broaden the diversity of portfolios a person manages. In ETFs trading fees can quickly add up and affect your investment's performance. Lack of liquidity is another major concern with ETFs.

1 comment

šŸ‘ 0
Donald Kieran Ang
Donald Kieran Ang

02 Apr 2019

Can't do monthly investment by byying ETFs yourself through brokers unlike regular top ups to robo advisors right?