Asked by Anonymous
Below 1 TIE Ratio for consecutive years is a definite red flag for me. This means they can't even produce enough earnings to cover the interest payments owed by them to their creditors. If their assets aren't able to pay off their debtors, equity holders will get absolutely nothing (hyflux). A big big lesson to learn there is that we need to be extremely clear that private companies aren't going to be bailed out by the government because of poor management, and unrated bonds must have even higher scrutiny involved regarding financial statements to see that they can meet their obligations.
Some red flags I would look out for include 1) Turnover of CFO, 2) high profits, low cashflow, 3) frequent, non-recurring gains (or losses)
The turnover rate of CFO could give insights into how the finances of the company is panning out. The CFO has first-hand information about where the revenues are generated, where the outflows are, what the ROI is and how the resources are allocated. A CFO quiting could potentially mean the company is headed for disaster or that the company is doing something behind the scene that requires some scrutiny.
A profitable company with insufficient cashflow can put the company at risk of bankruptcy. For example, Toys "R" Us initially was a profitable business however year or year it had an increasing cash outflow required to service its interest payments. Due to the huge interest payment and decreasing sales, the firm was forced into bankruptcy.
Non-recurring gains and losses should not occur frequently because they do not relate to normal business operations. If there is a trend of non-recurring gains and losses, it could be that the company is finding ways to write off or write down transactions to make the business look a certain way.
One ratio that I might want to take a closer look at is the Debt Service Coverage Ratio, which is a measurement of the cash flow available to pay current debt obligations.
While TIE and DSCR essentially measures the same thing, DSCR is slightly more comprehensive, assessing the ability of a company to meet its minimum principal on top of interest payments.
Lenders will routinely assess a borrower's DSCR before making a loan. A DSCR of less than 1 means that the borrower will be unable to cover or pay current debt obligations without drawing on outside sources – without, in essence, borrowing more.
Beside the usual red flags, there are other things to take note as below:
Some that I look out for:
Low profit margins or falling margins
Very high debt