Expenses Tracking

Family

General

Asked by Anonymous

Updated 2w ago

How do married couples share your kids expenses? Share which method your are using here! I have put four ideas here but interested to know more?

1) 50-50 - Both parties contribute same amount every month 2) Go by % of income - Both parties contribute same % of their income every month 3) 100% from Man of the Household 4) Maintain individual savings account 5) Any others?

2

Answers (13)

Sort By

Most Upvote

  • Most Upvote
  • Most Recent
Kenneth Lou
Kenneth Lou, Co-founder at Seedly
Level 8. Wizard
Updated 2w ago

There is no right answer to this! But let me try to paint it clearer for the others to understand.

1) 50-50 - Both parties contribute same amount every month

I think while this sounds logical, may not be sustainable eg some couples sometimes may have different earning power, but the kids are both their responsibilities.

2) Go by % of income - Both parties contribute same % of their income every month

This one seems pretty modern and also the most utalitatian (fair) way to do it. But also need to have common understanding on both sides that by both increasing income, it helps the overall situation. In fact, I think this could work by creating a seperate savings account (eg CIMB Fastsaver at 1% p.a) joint account to withdraw from here.

A shared expense - their kids.

3) 100% from Man of the Household

I think this way is not the modern way to do it, used to see other families and my mum sharing from some of her colleages that if the wife stays home, that is where she gets a allowance + family maintainence that she will have to budget for groceries and kids etc.

4) Maintain individual savings account

I think this may also result in miscommunications which is not so ideal in a long relationship. Money often is the core of most relationship problems.

5) Paying for certain activities (or by respective kid). MY WAY

This example is the one my parents used to raise us up. Both are working adults and worked hard to provide for my brother and I.

  • For tuition, enrichment classes, presents, gifts rewards (for me and my bro) - My Mum covered these
  • For groceries, petrol, ultilities, and bills - My dad will cover all these

So far, we've grown up well, and my family has a strong sense of financial independence and know-how imparting good money values to us as well. So I guess this kinda worked?

At the end of the day, find your own way and stick with it!

4 comments

4
Kenneth Lou
Kenneth Lou

26 Sep 2018

LOL. Oops. @Yixuan
HC Tang
HC Tang

24 Sep 2018

@Yixuan Hello.. haha. .there is .. just that we're not so lucky to bump into one :P hehe

See all 4 comments

ET
Eugene Tan Jia Rong,
Level 2. Rookie
Updated 2w ago

My Wife and I earn roughly around the same. We have 2 kids, one is special needs requiring expensive therapy. as such, kids education alone takes up 40% of our income alone.

For Shared expenses, here’s our split (Which is roughly 50-50 in our household):

1) Kids education - as wife is the trustee of the kids‘ CDA, she handles all education payments including monthly CDA top-ups. She also handles the kids insurance.

2) Utilities, conservancy & broadband - Wife

3) Car loan, petrol & parking - Me

4) Domestic helper - me

5) Groceries - me

6) Dining & entertainment - Me

1 comment

3
Leong Wen Fong
Leong Wen Fong

26 Sep 2018

Ooh actually is it better to split the bills in a way that someone is always in charge of something so that we wont miss anything out?

For my dad, it is : 3) 100% from Man of the Household since he earns more than mum

Both has individual account, besides his own expenses for work & insurance, he just

1) Pays for all the bills, utlities, groceries.

2) Allocate a portion for investment for the family future

3) Save a small amount for emergency funds in case of jobless / between jobs

4) Save a small portion monthly for seasonale gifts such as CNY Ang Pow for Mum, kids, Parent in law, gifts of mum/kids birthday, children's day, mother's day, Christmas etc.

5) Finally, balance all goes to mum to pay for everything else such as school fees, enrichment, tuitions and for mum to safe keep in case of any accident or mishap, mum and children will always be taken care off.

=> This is because mum is a very prudent woman who doesn't spend $ on clothings, branded goods etc and very sensible, practical with $ and living and absolutely hate wastage. Thus Dad trusted mum 100% with all that he earns and as the Finance Minister. After all, since he has chosen to married mum and have us as kids, all that he work for is towards the family well being and he kept hs own spending / entertainment cost minimum.

Since Dad contributed all that he has, so whatever mum earns, she will pay for anything else that she think is good for the children with their shared pool of $ or her own earnings.

2 comments

3
HC Tang
HC Tang

26 Sep 2018

Thanks. Haha :)
Kenneth Lou
Kenneth Lou

26 Sep 2018

This is a good one! An all-round complete answer haha
Lim Tian Shang
Lim Tian Shang,
Level 3. Wonderkid
Answered on 24 Sep 2018

100 😄 We do not separate between wife or husband.

0 comments

2
Thanh Dat
Thanh Dat,
Level 3. Wonderkid
Answered on 25 Mar 2019

Hi members,

As a married couples, as a husband and wife, communication is important. For my family is this way how we managed our family. I earn more than my wife. I'm the planner. I have a boy and gal.

I copy from Members Eugene Tan Jia Rong template for easy viewing as point form.

1) Kid education - I'm my son (5yo) trustee of the kid CDA, I will handles all my son education payments including CDA top-ups while my wife did it for my gal (16yo) Vietnamese secondary 3. I also handles all my family medical insurance. For my gal education later part we plan to use CPF to fund for her study depand on situation in another 2 years time.

2) Utilities, conservancy & broadband - Me

3) Passing weekly school allowance - Wife, but I may help at time.

4) Groceries - me if we go together, I look after my son milk supply. :). If she go solo with my son n gal. She paid.

5) Dining & entertainment - Me. Sometimes she would said treat me. ;)

6) Saving raining day: Me

7) Investment: Me, just last week spend $1000 on buying gold bracelet and pendants for my wife. (Before when we are in hard time, we will pawn the gold for cash for temporary support). Time are good now. Increase gold asset for my wife.

8) Fixed deposit: Me (Coming June)

0 comments

1
Colin Lim
Colin Lim,
Level 3. Wonderkid
Answered on 24 Sep 2018

there is no formula...u and your spouse have to discuss and conclude who have to contribute more..

from experience.. husband always on household expenses...wife on kids... if wife not working den husband pay everything. if wife earns more den probably wife contributes more..

ultimately discussion between couples is neccessarily.

give a like if u find it beneficial.

0 comments

1

That depends whether the household income comes from one party or both.

One party is str forward

Both party will come with a decision based on 1. How they split the household expenses 2. How they are paying their ppty loan

All before the baby arrived.

The earning power for each party will usually be the deciding factor who pays more and which is the best strategy in contributing.

Do think about it.

Hope my reply helps.

If you feel this reply have Quality, please upvote and check other Quality Reply.

https://seedly.sg/profile/a-kenichi-xi

Thank you.

0 comments

1
Nicholas Chan
Nicholas Chan,
Level 5. Genius
Answered on 24 Sep 2018

If similar thoughts on personal finance & spending habits, easier to pool finances together, includes both assets & liabilities. Optimise as a couple.

0 comments

1
Kok Koon
Kok Koon,
Level 5. Genius
Updated on 26 Mar 2019

We are still figuring out (1.5years married nia) but so far, it goes by the bandwidth and strength of the spouse.

I'm managing the investments, protection and retirement planning while le-wife takes care of the holidays, bills payment and automation. Her paying for our daily spending is more frequent using her miles card but I do the lump sum transfer like refunding the housing grant and helping her hit FRS fast.

As far as it goes, my money is ours and her money is ours. It might seem the contribution is disproportionate but the circumstances may change with economy and career stability or health crisis. I always say I'll never know one day we may depend on her income.

The spilt and management will be unique to individual couples. Kids will be another area of management but we work on getting a common approach that fits both our value systems.

That's our fulfilment of vows made to each other - that all my worldy goods I endow to thee. :D

0 comments

0
Tan Chin Yu
Tan Chin Yu,
Level 3. Wonderkid
Answered on 24 Sep 2018

Both contribute into a fixed pool, then work out all savings and expenses from there.

0 comments

0
Good Day Every Day
Good Day Every Day,
Level 6. Master
Answered on 24 Sep 2018

Both parties share the kids expenses equally. Both parties are responsible for each other and to the kids.

0 comments

0
Yong Kah Hwee
Yong Kah Hwee,
Level 6. Master
Answered on 24 Sep 2018

I would vote for 2) Go by % of income.

0 comments

0
Png Cheng Xi Damien
Png Cheng Xi Damien, BSc Finance at SUSS
Level 4. Prodigy
Answered on 24 Sep 2018

% of total income is the modern way of settling this.

0 comments

0