Anonymous

16 Jul 2020

∙

Do people try to replicate ETF holdings?

Discussion (4)

What are your thoughts?

Learn how to style your text

Tan Kel Vin

16 Jul 2020

Financial YouTuber at Kelvin Learns Investing

I use ETF holdings as a reference to build my shopping list. Then only buy the better performing stocks

Save

Eddy He

15 Jul 2020

If you have enough money and the time to monitor/rebalance your portfolio then probably yes but the tracking error would be huge if it's not automated. Otherwise just invest in a ETF with low expense ratio will do.

Save

James ng

15 Jul 2020

It’s almost impossible to replicate ETF holdings with low tracking error....

Write your thoughts

Why do people like to use FSMOne to sell SG stocks? A bit confused as to how it works and what are the benefits of that? Also why do people like to use FSMOne to RSP into ETFs? And why RSP into ETFs?

For stock, how many sectors should I invest in? If I hold ETF, should I still get the stock that is within the ETF? Any pro and con to hold more stock vs less stock?

I am currently holding some Xtrackers MSCI China UCITS ETF. Will it make sense for me to also hold some Lion-OCBC Securities China Leaders ETF?

Which broker to use for US ETF e.g. vanguard snp 500? Saxo or td ameritrade. Quite confused by the many costs.. Also, is roboadvisors another “alternative” to invest in us etf? I would like to buy and hold US etf, before dabbling in the rest.?

Which ETF is a better buy and hold for 2 decades to ride China's growth? China ETF : iShares MSCI China ETF (MCHI) vs xTrackers Harvest CSI 300 (ASHR)?

Moomoo Singapore

4.7

476 Reviews

From $0

MINIMUM FEE

0.03%

TRADING FEES

Custodian

STOCK HOLDING TYPE

Saxo Markets

4.5

956 Reviews

Syfe Trade

4.9

124 Reviews

Why do people like to use FSMOne to sell SG stocks? A bit confused as to how it works and what are the benefits of that? Also why do people like to use FSMOne to RSP into ETFs? And why RSP into ETFs?

For stock, how many sectors should I invest in? If I hold ETF, should I still get the stock that is within the ETF? Any pro and con to hold more stock vs less stock?

I am currently holding some Xtrackers MSCI China UCITS ETF. Will it make sense for me to also hold some Lion-OCBC Securities China Leaders ETF?

Which ETF is a better buy and hold for 2 decades to ride China's growth? China ETF : iShares MSCI China ETF (MCHI) vs xTrackers Harvest CSI 300 (ASHR)?