2nd Property for investment returns, is it still worth it given the ABSD is 12%. Your property needs to grow 12% just to match this initial "loss". Go for it or just buy stocks/ REITS? - Seedly
Seedly logo
Seedly logo




Stocks Discussion

Cedric Jamie Soh

Asked on 10 Jun 2019

2nd Property for investment returns, is it still worth it given the ABSD is 12%. Your property needs to grow 12% just to match this initial "loss". Go for it or just buy stocks/ REITS?

I have been thinking stocks and reits are still better than property investments, but I am curious why are still so many Singaporeans looking to buy their 2nd property after they meet their HDB 5 years MOP. Any people in similar shoes in 2nd property or sticking to stocks and REITS only?


5 answers

Answer Now

Answers (5)

Sort By

People sometimes just need to "feel" the investment. There are many who would avoid stocks and REITs because it's "paper" to them. No feel.

So if you're looking for a reliable stream of income for rental, dividends, or coupons, paper assets will be so much cheaper to purchase and hold.

You don't want to be stuck with an illiquid physical asset which costs you so much in fees just to "feel" your investment.

1 comment

ūüĎć 3
Cedric Jamie Soh
Cedric Jamie Soh

10 Jun 2019

Thats a good answer. the "feel" is really important for a lot of Asians.
James Yeo
James Yeo, Founder at SmallCapAsia.com
Level 5. Genius
Answered on 10 Jun 2019

I would advise against it. Interest rates can increase dramatically in the event of overheating.

$1mil loan at 2% is $20k yearly, $1.667k monthly.

Loan at 5% is $4,167 monthly. And if recession hits and one of you or your partner loses the job, would you have the cash cushion to tie over the period or be willing to force-sell the ppty at a huge loss?

Go for REITs can bail out anytime using just 1 click.


ūüĎć 1
Gabriel Tham
Gabriel Tham, Kenichi Tag Team Member at Tag Team
Level 9. God of Wisdom
Answered on 10 Jun 2019

Some buy in hopes of en bloc.

Some buy so next time children can inherit while renting out in the short term.

Some might buy to keep mistress? Maybe? haha


ūüĎć 1
Ryan Pham
Ryan Pham
Level 3. Wonderkid
Answered on 18 Jun 2019

In today's property market, most will not get breakeven properties let alone cashflow positive.

The mortgage interest rates and the demand for rentals in most areas are not helping. So most of the time, alot of properties will be cashflow negative so if its your second property, I would advice against buying it for now and maybe put the CPF money into CPFIS Reits.

Im not saying there isnt any good properties with positive cashflow but its going to be very hard to find.

By the way, dont look at positive ROI you must calculate positive cashflow. Its important because you can be positive in ROI but bleeding money monthly and cause you more pain than gain.


ūüĎć 0
Takingstock @
Takingstock @
Level 6. Master
Answered on 12 Jun 2019

Having looked at friends and assessing the case now, I would say its not worth it.

A) diversification - stocks + reits are better

A property is just one. It could be somewhere from 0.3 million to 40 million by itself. Given the market conditions now, its really difficult to get a rental yield that you can say is really impressive?

On the other hand, with 0.3 million, you could pretty much build a decent portfolio that is well diversified and not having the risk of "one".

B) Ease of liquidity - stocks and reits better

Its really easier to sell stocks and reits using a few clicks. With a property you gotta engage an agent, put up listings, look out when govt may raise absd, check whether you are in the time range for seller stamp duty.....

C) debt - stocks and reits better

With property, you usually need to take a loan and that introduces interest rate risk apart from having to ensure you can service the monthly payments.

With stocks and reits, you can adjust the quantity and be decently invested without having to leverage.

D) managing tenants - stocks and reits better

Stocks and reits have entire teams working to get business / tenants and pay you dividends. You dont need to work to get your dividends.

With property, hell no. You look for tenants, negotiate rents, address their needs and complaints. Why you want to do extra work?

E) taxes - stocks and reits better

Property - just the property tax alone, you might be disadvantaged in the p&l / yield already. Then comes rental income. And additional work to incorporate this in your tax filing.

Dividends from stocks and reits are usually not taxed (at least for Singapore stocks). They win hands down.


ūüĎć 0