facebookShould I rush to get a Critical Illness plan before Aug 2020, or will there be advantages in waiting? - Seedly



29 Jan 2020


Should I rush to get a Critical Illness plan before Aug 2020, or will there be advantages in waiting?

For context, Critical illness definition is going to be changed on 26 Aug 2020.

Are the old terms better than the new terms?

Discussion (11)

What are your thoughts?

Learn how to style your text

Leslie Koh

Leslie Koh

29 Jan 2020

Associate Financial Services Manager at Prudential Assurance Company Singapore

If you are sufficiently covered, there’s no need to rush to get a CI coverage just because of a few changes in definitions.

But if you’re already planning to get life insurance with CI coverage, you’ll want to consider whether the current definitions are more lenient and to your advantage.

Josh Tan Jian Liang

Josh Tan Jian Liang

23 Oct 2019

Co-founder https://theastuteparent.com at Promiseland Independent Pte Ltd

As medical science advances, new medical definitions come up all the time.

The objective is to reflect medical changes and REDUCE ambiguity as they arise.

Analysis of the key changes by understanding the TOP 5 CI claims Do you know that 90 per cent of all severe stage claims received by life insurers are for five critical illnesses:

  1. major cancer
  2. heart attack of specified severity
  3. stroke with permanent neurological deficit
  4. coronary artery bypass surgery
  5. end-stage kidney failure.

This part is to examine how the new definitions reduce ambiguity by explicitly stating exclusions.

1) Major Cancer:

It is now specified that: "Major Cancer diagnosed on the basis of finding tumour cells and/or tumour-associated molecules in the blood, saliva, faeces, urine or any other bodily fluid in the absence of further definitive and clinically verifiable evidence does not meet the above definition".

There are cancer marker tests these days using body fluids but the conclusion is often with a scan. This is to specify that conclusive proof is needed NOT that it wasn't already previously.

In the exclusions list, MORE has been explicitly stated. I'd highlight two of them

A) Carcinoma-in-situ (Tis) or Ta;

Below is an image (on bladder cancer) to possibly help you understand more on Carcinoma in situ (Tis) or Ta since it is common these days.

Carcinoma in situ (also called CIS or Tis) means very early, high grade cancer cells. It is a non-invasive cancer of the flat urothelial or transitional cells. Source.

Ta is now explicitly stated to be excluded moving forward.

B) All grades of dysplasia, squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSIL and LSIL) and intra epithelial neoplasia.

This is to specifically state because dysplasia, squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSIL and LSIL) and intra epithelial neoplasia requires further testing.

Previously, the exclusion explicitly stated was only Cervical Dysplasia CIN-1, CIN-2 and CIN-3. NOT that HSIL and LSIL were previously payable.

2) Heart Attack of specified severity

The new definition is Death of heart muscle "due to ischaemia" vs "due to obstruction of blood flow".

Medical professionals use Ischaemia and medically it is the same thing.

LIA specified that it replaced “obstruction of blood flow” with “ischaemia” to reflect the intent to cover Type 1 MI and Type 2 MI.

I did some further reading and there is Type 3 MI which is actually for deaths due to heart attack before conclusions can be made. (source).

In any case, death to the patient happened before the CI survival period so it is not for discussion here.

3) Stroke with Permanent Neurological Deficit

From LIA: Deleted “with persisting clinical symptoms” as not necessary.

In my opinion, this simply is one less criterion which is good for claiming.

From LIA: Sometimes, after a cranial surgery, the pathological analysis of the resected tumour could show signs of “intra tumour” bleeding. Whilst there is intracranial or cerebrovascular bleeding, it is not a valid claim under the Stroke definition.

This is to remove ambiguity (by explicitly putting into exclusions) in my opinion for patients who exhibit stroke-like symptoms due to cranial surgeries. 4) Coronary Artery By-pass Surgery

No changes made.

5) End-stage kidney failure

LIA changed the header to reflect the intent of end-stage.

BUT new definitions or old is not the REAL QUESTION.

Moreover, there will likely be another "revised new definition" a few years later again.

If you have a shortfall in coverage, get insured NOW because critical illness (CI) can impact you from a sudden disease or a sudden trauma.

In addition, there is usually a further 90 day waiting period from your policy before you can claim for Critical illness (CI). Hope it helps.

To read more: https://www.theastuteparent.com/2019/10/new-cri...

Kelly Trinh

Kelly Trinh

15 Oct 2019

Backoffice technical at financial services firm

In contrast with the other answers here.... I am an actuary.

While there are some corner cases wh...

Read 4 other comments with a Seedly account

You will also enjoy exclusive benefits and get access to members only features.

Sign up or login with an email here

Write your thoughts