facebookDoes it make a difference whether you do lump sum or DCA for robo-advisors? - Seedly

Anonymous

07 Feb 2021

Robo-Advisors

Does it make a difference whether you do lump sum or DCA for robo-advisors?

Is there a difference between DCA every month or putting a lump sum for robo-advisors such as Syfe? Let's say usually people have a ‘guideline’ of investing 20% of their salary per month then if i do lump sum maybe every 6 months or so must i hit that 20% also?

Discussion (3)

What are your thoughts?

Learn how to style your text

Bullythebear

07 Feb 2021

Tutor at Self employed

Let me offer an alternative view. Say you already have the money to do either lump sum or DCA, which will you choose?

Lump-sum is good if you can time the market. It can be TA or fundamentals based, or even just a flat out algorithm like this: "IF portfolio drops 5% from last high, BUY more". Basically, it involves work on your part, so you want to invest because of you.

If you don't want to do any of these, or don't know how, then you do DCA. That's just passively putting more in every month without you controlling. You want to invest in spite of you.

Zac

06 Feb 2021

Noob at Idiots Invest

If you lump-sum every 6 months - where does the lump-sum come from? If you set aside 20% of your salary each month for investment, your 6-month lump-sum will also be 20% of your 6-months' salary.

Chris

06 Feb 2021

Owner and Writer at Tortoisemoney.com

Technically, putting in the whole amount that you intend to invest from your salary in each month, i...

Write your thoughts