facebookBetween ETF and unit trust, which would you prefer and why? - Seedly

Anonymous

15 Apr 2020

General Investing

Between ETF and unit trust, which would you prefer and why?

What are the different mechanics and how do you know which is a better investment for you?

Discussion (4)

What are your thoughts?

Learn how to style your text

Unit Trusts = more or less Mutual Fund congener, mostly active management, only one price fixing per day, mostly very high annual fees (more than 0.30%), mostly underperforming, not recommended!

ETFs: often passively managed, real time prices per trading, often low annual fees (less than 0.30%), performance very near to the imaged index. Modern fair investing instrument, highly recommended.​​​

View 1 replies

Shengshi Chiam, CFA

27 Apr 2020

Personal Finance Lead at Endowus

Hi. I can understand the confusion! The first passively managed unit trust that I invested in so happens to be with Endowus, and previously i always have made the association that unit trusts are ALL actively managed, which is factually wrong.

Unit trusts, or mutual funds, can be actively or passively managed.

ETFs can be actively or passively managed too.

The difference is the unit trusts/mutual funds are not exchange traded, and created or redeemed by the fund manager at the end of the day at the fund's Net Asset Value (NAV)

ETFs, in contrast, are exchange traded, so it has higher liquidity, You will buy it like a stock, but as with exchange traded product, there is a bid ask spread and you will likely not be able to buy at the actual value of the funds (or NAV).

Hope that answers your question. Indexed, low costs funds are what we tend to prefer, because they are more diversified and deliver long term consistent returns, if they are globally diversified. Whether it is an ETF or a unit trust is secondary.​​​

View 1 replies

You pay additional fees to unit trust for risk management as well as exposure to markets that are not given to a normal retail investor.

I would manage my expectations on outperformance for unit trusts. If you accept that outperformance over the long term is generally not achievable than it would be better to stick to an ETF.

Colin Lim

25 Apr 2020

Financial Services Consultant at Colin Lim

Hope u already found the answer... I realise this question is so long ago.. And people repeat the answer and get points..

UTs can be actively managed and passively managed by 2 different schools of fund managers. UTs charges are relatively higher than ETFs because of this feature.

Pang Zhe Liang

25 Apr 2020

Fee-Based Financial Advisory Manager at Financial Alliance Pte Ltd (IFA Firm)

Unit trust is actively managed by a professional fund manager. Generally, its objective may be to ou...

Write your thoughts