facebookWhat is the difference between buying the ETFs - Nikko (A35), ABF (G3B) from blue-chips (via Bank - Posb Invest Saver etc) as compared to purchasing them directly? - Seedly

What is the difference between buying the ETFs - Nikko (A35), ABF (G3B) from blue-chips (via Bank - Posb Invest Saver etc) as compared to purchasing them directly?

As my subject title has stated, wondering which would be more feasible? Are there any pros and cons etc?

Discussion (1)

What are your thoughts?

Learn how to style your text

Kenneth Lou

20 Aug 2019

Co-founder at Seedly

Hey Zach! To answer your question simply, the main considerations here are:

  • Cost per trade
  • Flexibility on entry and exit of the stock

If you were to use the BCIP or RSP from any of the banks (eg OCBC BCIP or POSB invest saver)

Pros:

  • You can set and forget (one time setup)
  • Basically it will auto deduct on every 14th or 15th of the month that stipulated amount
  • This is true dollar cost averaging

Cons:

  • You don't get to choose the date you want to enter (to buy the stock)
  • The costs is really high. considering that it is 1% of every amount that you invest.

If you do it on your own directly by trading via your own brokerage

Pros:

  • You decide at what price you want to enter
  • Your cost can be cheaper if you use options like cash upfront, at $10 per trade, and if you trade more than $1,000, it will already be more worth it (less than 1%)

Cons:

  • It is more tedious to setup, you will need to have your own brokerage and CDP setup
  • You will need to enter the market at your own time (ie trying to time the market) Hope this helps! We also wrote a pretty in depth piece here: https://blog.seedly.sg/spdr-sti-etf-vs-nikko-am-sti-etf/

Write your thoughts