facebookUnit trust - Can I consult fund managers? If I can learn how they rebalance portfolios, I see the fees as an investment. - What services do FMs offer that roboadvisors don't? - How do I 'screen' FMs? - Seedly

Advertisement

Unit trust - Can I consult fund managers? If I can learn how they rebalance portfolios, I see the fees as an investment. - What services do FMs offer that roboadvisors don't? - How do I 'screen' FMs?

I am a newbie investor whose bank rep recently introduced to unit trusts. While I definitely cannot DIY, I am wary as I heard this 'active form' of investing do not outperform passive investing by much, thus not justifying their management fees. I am also considering a mix of cash management funds, 2 or 3 ETFs or a roboadvisor. Any advice is welcomed thanks!

Discussion (14)

What are your thoughts?

Learn how to style your text

If you new to investing, start with low-cost options like ETFs or roboadvisors—cheap and simple. If you want active management, choose unit trusts with good track records and reasonable fees, but don’t expect them to always beat the market. Always watch fees, stay diversified, and don’t panic when market goes up and down.

Billy

05 Mar 2025

Development & Acquisitions Manager at Real Estate Private Equity

Hi Claudia! Perhaps to provide further clarification:

Fund Houses = Allianz | State Street Global Advisors | Vanguard

Fund Manager = Ray Dalio | George Soros | Jim Simons

Funds = SPDR STI ETF | VOO | CSPX | XLF etc.

Funds: 2 main styles as you accurately indicated

Active funds - Frequent rebalancing / trading (Roboadvisors)

Passive funds - Rebalance only when necessary (i.e. ETFs - VOO, CSPX)

Within the realm of funds there's also funds tracking different products - Gold, Indexes, Fixed Income, Oil, Agriculture etc.

Management fees are usually charged as a % of Assets Under Management (AUM) which essentially means the total value of one's portfolio. Hence its an added incentive for fund managers to perform well.

To "screen" FMs, you can take a look at their NAV of their funds which are usually available on their website (or on brokerages such as Fundsupermart). You can take a look at historical returns (for funds focusing on capital appreciation) & historical yields (for funds with payouts). You may also view the frequency of distribution too. Some funds offer annual payouts, some half yearly, some quarterly, some monthly as well.

Cash management accounts / funds offer a good alternative / yield as opposed to the declining TBill returns. While its not 100% guaranteed, so far its been so good.

ETFs - really dependent on what you select. I would go for more index ETFs if I'm looking for something long-term / less volatile.

Roboadvisor - Honestly wouldn't recommend, I deposited $500 in Dec 2020 just for fun with a risk profile at maximum 36%. Max drawdown was 20% (-$100) in 2023 and it subsequently recovered to the current levels of $558. So essentially 5 years, my capital only increased by ~10% which equates to a 2% annual increase. In comparison VOO increased 94%

Kenneth Chan

05 Mar 2025

Wealth Manager at Phillip Capital

I think they may be RMs instead of FMs. I run different portfolios at Phillip Capital (poems), and to be honest, index is the low cost way to start on your own, if you have the discipline. Can drop me a DM if you want to chat more, we have very competitive fees for DIY investors who are "Buy Term, Invest the Rest."

Just avoid those FI and go for robo

As a retail investor, we usually do not have access to fund managers. they are like the Buffetts and...

Write your thoughts

Advertisement