facebookShouldn't the government's goal be to seek to make inflation 0%, not 2%? I don't understand why they want prices to appreciate, won't that be bad for everyone? - Seedly


18 Dec 2019

General Investing

Shouldn't the government's goal be to seek to make inflation 0%, not 2%? I don't understand why they want prices to appreciate, won't that be bad for everyone?

Is inflation even necessary? Why can't the government just make it 0% inflation?!

Discussion (4)

What are your thoughts?

Learn how to style your text

Baey Ee-Qiang David

18 Dec 2019

CEO and Co-Founder at Mortgage Master Singapore

Hmmm perhaps the answer need not be on a factual level but on a literal level to your question.

A Government's goal is to make the country strong, financially and economically.

Taking inflation as mild inflation (The 2% kind) not the 20% kind (hyper inflation), and explaining why it is good in layman terms will be like this.

Take Singapore as an example. Last time $3 in 2000 can buy 1 packet chicken rice.

Now $3.50 then can buy.

Last time my fresh graduate from NUS in 2009 was paid $2,700 a month or 900 packets of chicken rice a month.

Now fresh graduate is paid $3,150 a month. Eh same leh 900 packets of chicken rice.

As such inflation actually did not cause any problems for people who get pay increments at the same rate as inflation. (This is fair, see below paragraph)

(A whole different topic, but in 2009 person "A" was paid $2,700 as an engineer. "A"did not get promoted as "A" was slack. in 2019 "A" waspaid $3,150 as an engineer doing the exact same job. This is normal. To earn more "A" has to hit stretch goals and get promoted.)

Returning back to the government point.

But then now, you have to use your imagination a bit.

In a nearby country where the currency is $1 is to $1 to Singapore, inflation did not happen.

in fact deflation happened. so last time you go there $3 buy one chicken rice, not you go there $2 can buy already.

Remove imagination and return to reality. This doesn't really happen. The way finance works is that actually the currency gets valued as a lesser or weaker currency. (Malaysia)

In Malaysia, Malaysians still buy chicken rice at $3 but is in ringgit

So now your $1 can change $3 in the nearby country!

Without considering other country factors. Which finance minister did a better job over the past 10 years?

If you think the Singapore finance minister did a better job, then you understand why mild inflation is good lor.​​​

Kenneth Fong

04 Dec 2019

Marketing Manager at Seedly

That's a good question!

Shouldn't the government be reducing inflation to 0%? That way, we won't have to spend so much money on stuff what!

Well... Yes, and unfortunately, No.

I'm going to explain why inflation is important using something we're all familiar with: ice cream.

TL;DR: Why Is Inflation Needed In Our Economy?

Many economists, businessmen, and politicians believe that inflation, or the gradual increase of prices over time, helps keep businesses profitable and prevents consumers from simply waiting for lower prices before making purchases.

On the other hand, rising prices also makes doing stuff like saving money harder. It causes individuals to engage in riskier strategies in order to increase or just to maintain their wealth.

And as with anything that is remotely linked to the government, people are sure to suspect that inflation is just an excuse for some businesses or individuals to benefit at the expense of others.

Defining Inflation

Imagine that it's after school. And there are 10 kids who all love ice cream.

The ice cream uncle standing outside school, only has 5 servings left in his cart. And he is selling them at $1 each.

Each kid has $2 in hand and all of them want to have ice cream. The enterprising uncle realises that he can get more for his ice cream so he jacks up the price to $2.

This $1 increase is a result of Demand Pull Inflation or excess demand of a scarce good.

The next day, the uncle heads to the ice cream factory to get a restock of ice cream. The supplier informs him that milk prices have increased, so he is selling 10 blocks of ice cream at $100 instead of $80.

The ice cream uncle knows that he gets 200 servings of ice cream from 10 blocks. And this $20 increase means that if he wants to make the same profit, he must now sell his ice cream at $1.10 instead of $1.

This is a result of Supply Push Inflation, which is caused by a substantial increase in the cost of important goods or services where no suitable alternative is available.

After all, he can't make ice cream out of water right? So bobian, he has to buy the product in order to make a living.

Inflation In The Real World

When everyone in an economy is expecting say... A 10% inflation, everyone adjusts their prices upwards by 10%. Suddenly your pint of milk costs $1.10 (from $1), your loaf of bread costs $3.30 (from $3), and your McSpicy meal costs... Well, you get the picture.

This was EXACTLY what happened in the States during the 1970s where everyone expected double digit inflation due to high oil prices.

In fact, people started factoring this inflationary expectation into their wages and prices of goods. Unfortunately, this expectation was allowed to develop and continued without significant economic growth which resulted in Stagflation.

The result? Unemployment rates rose to an astronomical high and the US economy went into a recession.

The world has learnt from this mistake though.

So as a result, governments try to limit inflationary expectations by stating outright what the target inflation rate for the year is. This is why you'll notice that MAS makes a huge point every end of the year to announce what the target inflation rate for the next year will be.

It'll usually be a sustainable and healthy level of inflation. Not high enough to turn your cash savings into "banana money" (read: currency used during the Japanese occupation which became worthless due to inflation).

But high enough to create a sufficient buffer before deflation happens.

Asset Bubbles: The Calm Before The Deflation Storm

Asset Bubbles occur when Demand Push Inflation causes assets to become overvalued.

Let's say all the cool kids at school think that having an ice cream after school is the trendy thing to do. The uncle decides to up the cool factor by branding his ice cream with a trademarked logo and prices his ice cream at $10 (remember that it only costs him $0.80 to make one before the supplier increased the price of ice cream).

It's all the rage amongst the kids, and every one at school is either begging their parents to get them this "branded" ice cream or are saving up their pennies just to buy one.

One day, the popular kids are sick of the uncle's ice cream and refuse to even pay cost price for the ice cream.

The asset (ice cream) bubble has just burst, and what follows is deflation.

Cue (ice) screams

Sorry, couldn't help it.

The Problem Of Deflation

Remember the 10 kids who used to buy ice cream from the uncle? They all still have $2 to spend, but they're no longer interested in spending it on ice cream because it's not trendy anymore.

Instead, they're buying Korean instant noodles because that's what all their K-Drama idols are eating.

On Monday, the uncle sells his ice cream at $1. The next week, he drops it to $0.90 because the kids still aren't buying.

A month in, he drops it to $0.80 out of desperation.

Some of the kids start to wonder if they should have ice cream, because it's cheaper at $0.80 now. But they also can't help but wonder if it'll drop to $0.50 and that's when they can have 2 ice creams for the price of one.

"Shiok! Deflation is great! I can buy 2 ice creams sia..." Gerald, one of the kids, exclaims.

A couple of months later, 90% of ice cream uncles in Singapore can't afford to keep their carts because they can't pay for the ice cream distribution license. Gerald's dad, who also happens to be an ice cream uncle loses his job.

And guess what? Gerald now has no pocket money for ice cream or Korean instant noodles...

Closing Thoughts

Inflation is a 'necessary evil' that helps keep the world economy functional.

If you're concerned about inflation eating up the value of your dollar, Seedly has a great piece written on why investing can help you to overcome inflation. Do check it out.

Cedric Jamie Soh

03 Jun 2019

Director at Seniorcare.com.sg

Deflation sucks. Mild Inflation is needed so that we won't ever be in deflation.

If you have defla...

Write your thoughts