facebookIs it better to invest one lump sum into different stock (and bonds) or spread it across many different months? - Seedly

Anonymous

13 Jun 2020

General Investing

Is it better to invest one lump sum into different stock (and bonds) or spread it across many different months?

I am new to investing and i heard the best way to invest is dollar cost averaging and to diversify. However, wouldn't the minimum fee for the brokerage account of $25 stack up like crazy if you do so? (assuming we ignore the other commission fee)

Example, i want to buy 5 stock and i do so every month is a year. The min fee would be $1500. That is a lot of money if i am playing with a few thousand dollars

Can you guys help me? I am interpreting the brokerage fee correctly or am i wrong ?

Discussion (6)

What are your thoughts?

Learn how to style your text

Hello there! I noticed that your available capital for investing is limited in 4 digits range. Hence I understand your concern in brokerage fees stacking up if you DCA.

I would suggest NOT to DCA and NOT to diversify, ie. max 1-2 stocks in your current portfolio.

While saving some fees is one of the reasons, I encourage you to study deeply in the stocks that you are interested in, and buy the one you have the highest conviction with, while being prepared to hit a wall.

Investing is never easy and is a life long learning process. As an amateur, you are more likely to make mistakes in your first few investment decisions, and you can learn from the mistakes with minimal capital. This will speed up your long term personal growth in investing, instead of succumbing to the easiest way (DCA and ignore) at the start of your investing journey.​​​

View 1 replies

Ng Wei En

12 Jun 2020

Analyst at Mastercard

You are right that the commission fee of $25 takes up a significant percentage if your trade size are say in the low 4 digits. I am currently using FSMone which charges S$10 per trade for SG stocks and US$8.80 for US stocks. There are also brokers like Saxo and Interactive Brokers(IB) which charges less trading fees than $25. These brokers maintain your holdings in a Custodian account which is not the same as your existing broker which I believe maintains your holdings in your CDP account.

To know the difference between CDP and Custodian account, please refer to an article by Seedly here.

For a comparison of trading fees of stock brokerages in Singapore, you can refer to this cheatsheet by Seedly here.

View 3 replies

Write your thoughts